What members said
The board agreed to survey members on the new site. The pattern, not the people: club members cannot agree the new site is better than the one it replaced.
- Four in tenscored it below the midpoint when asked if it beats the old site.
“Just … reconsider the whole project. Was the new site built by people who never used the old site? The members never see the whole ride description because it’s hidden in boxes.”
Ride leader and volunteer, 10+ years in the club
“The listings on the old site [were] much clearer and also easier to read. Sorry to say but as far as I am concerned it is a very poor ROI after years under development.”
Ride leader and volunteer, 10+ years in the club
“Ride listings take several clicks just to see what the leader has posted. All feedback given during initial stages was ignored, even from UX and other professionals who work in the industry. The website has turned off new potential leaders.”
Ride leader and volunteer, 10+ years in the club
“UX design and layout for most screens is poor for its primary function for members: ride information. I speak from well over 30 years of experience building large professional public websites.”
Ride leader, 10+ years in the club
Member survey, Aug 16–30, 2026, run after a board motion: 119 responses. Quotes are anonymized by the survey.
What members did
Club leadership spent $198,712 on the new site. Members were split on it, and it did nothing to bring them back.
Fewer members ride.
Down for the second year in a row: 1,272, then 1,231, now 1,166.
Rides got emptier.
About a fifth fewer riders on the average club ride than a year ago.
Club ride records, 2026 against the same dates in 2025. Rider totals cover January 1 to October 16.
What $198,712 bought
Board minutes & financial statementsTwo ways to build a club website, side by side. Figures are from NYCC board minutes and financial statements.
| The official project | The member-built alternative | |
|---|---|---|
| Time | Since 2022. Rides app since Aug 2023. | About seven months. |
| Cost to members | $198,712 | $0 to the club |
| Launch | Promised spring 2025, then Dec 2025–Jan 2026. Live May 2026. | Working. A demo runs at demo.nyc-rides.bike.* |
| Ride history | None imported. | 30,000+ historical rides imported. |
* The member-built site ran at tools.nycc.org, where any member could log in and test it. Scott took it down after four board members asked him to.